|
Post by Amadan on Aug 15, 2024 6:08:40 GMT
wow. Just wow. Is this genuinely a serious post? How far back in time do you want to go. Do you want to take Russian history back to the Tsar as well for comparison? Try and keep your time lines comparable. To my knowledge there has been no independently monitored vote in the Donbass to see if a majority want to join Russia. Putin could have offered such a vote at any time instead of invading. Northern Ireland is today currently part of the uk , despite Sinn Fein historically winning elections , and unionism losing control of stormont for the first time in a century they are still being denied a border poll as per the GFA. The events of the troubles as was said up the page is within our lifetimes , so while history is relevant , we are discussing modern event as well , so your ancient history deflection is fatuous nonsense. Eh? You are of course deliberately avoiding the point in your own ignorance. Donbass is a part of the nation of Ukraine , and should remain a part of Ukraine , with the ethnic Russians treated equally and fairly as Ukrainian citizens. When did Northern Ireland get a vote to join the uk? The point is the Russians in Ukraine have done similar to the British in ireland , grabbed hold of a part of another country without a whiff of democracy. Thats why internationally people laugh at the British when they lecture other nations on their behaviour . No one takes you seriously .
|
|
|
Post by Amadan on Aug 15, 2024 6:13:12 GMT
Did Edinburgh have a massive fire in 1666? Was it bombed relentlessly by the Luftwaffe? Dun Eideann , to give it its proper Scottish name , had a great fire in 1824 monte , and was bombed by the Luftwaffe in the early part of the Second World War , and was bombed by the English for example in the 16th century.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 15, 2024 6:20:22 GMT
Did Edinburgh have a massive fire in 1666? Was it bombed relentlessly by the Luftwaffe? Take a look at some of the historical sites torn down in my hometown of Stoke Newington - nothing to do with either of those things The town hall - destroyed loads of old buildings to put it up in the 1930s Old lion statues removed from entrance to Green Lanes, they had entrances there once upon a time The big standing house at Abney Park cemetary - torn down purposefully Road widening on Stoke Newington Church Street meant demolition of the historic Red Lion pub and rebuilding a new one in its stead There are so many more examples - that's just from my hometown in London Look slightly further afield to somewhere like Waltham Cross in Herts, up from where I lived in Stoke Newington - one of the Eleanor Crosses was gotten rid of and they put a new one in its stead, IIRC they even removed THAT one to a museum at some point too and now what stands there is nothing like the original Are you not seeing the difference? Look at how much better they've tried to preserve their historic architecture I'm not trying to start an argument, I'm making an observation
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 15, 2024 6:23:54 GMT
London Wall, nothing to do with the Great Fire or air raids WikiFace facts, our politicians have rarely shown a care about our heritage, they want to tear it all down to make way for faceless business parks, wider roads and all kinds of other cac It will probably resemble where I currently live in suburban Atlanta in GA when they're done with it all
|
|
|
Post by Amadan on Aug 15, 2024 6:34:52 GMT
funny how we have radio silence over this? does no one want to discuss it? I remember vinny assuring me with screams and a frothing rage that Vladimir putin blew up his own pipeline , and vinny personally saw him do it. High energy prices , banning by our president of Europeans using Russian gas , labour bringing in austerity mark two and ending winter fuel payments , and refusing to fund Scotlands winter fuel payment which has been partially devolved ( meaning we have a £180 million shortfall ) could lead to an interesting winter ahead. For all the wrong reasons. Still , at least the vinny sheep and his ilk can scream incoherently on a daily basis regurgitated propaganda about the Ukraine war , while our champions of international affairs turn a blind eye to the genocide in the Middle East. As our pensioners freeze.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 15, 2024 6:39:19 GMT
I read that about Scottish WFPs on The National, it's really awful by the way. We all know parts of Scotland get extremely dangerously cold in winter and pensioners there need it even more than those south of the border.
It's pretty awful
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 15, 2024 6:44:44 GMT
Regarding the Nord Stream sabotage, I don't agree with it but Ukraine are desperate: who knows what will happen if Putin wins? They probably theorised that if they sabotage gas exports to Germany et al that would somehow damage Russia's economy.
A poorly thought through idea for intl diplomacy but I understand why people might think it would help in their desperation.
We know Putin is happy to kidnap orphans and commit horrific war crimes. That's true for Ukraine as well who's politicians idolise Nazi war criminal terrorist Stepan Bandera, and Ukie soldiers executed Russian POWs without trial - also unacceptable.
The war is a cluster of epic proportion, I'm really not a fan of politicians who idolise Nazi war criminal terrorists like Stepan Bandera. At the same time, it's because Russia invaded first that I'm still hoping Ukraine don't lose this war to Russia - even if the way Ukraine's govt and soldiers have acted is indefensible at times
The ongoing genocide in Gaza, the ongoing genocide in Darfur (sponsored by the West), the genocide in many other places ongoing is often downplayed by those who think Zelenskyy is some kind of perfect hero and the West should be allowed to invade Iraq and do whatever the heck it likes around the world.
|
|
|
Post by Amadan on Aug 15, 2024 6:46:09 GMT
I read that about Scottish WFPs on The National, it's really awful by the way. We all know parts of Scotland get extremely dangerously cold in winter and pensioners there need it even more than those south of the border. It's pretty awful dont know if you also read read Robertson and swinney are both getting stick over Robertsons meetings with the Israelis . As for the winter fuel payment cut backs by labour , I think it's a perfect storm waiting to happen. Talk about labour shooting themselves in the foot , and giving red meat to their political opponents.
|
|
|
Post by Amadan on Aug 15, 2024 6:50:27 GMT
Regarding the Nord Stream sabotage, I don't agree with it but Ukraine are desperate: who knows what will happen if Putin wins? They probably theorised that if they sabotage gas exports to Germany et al that would somehow damage Russia's economy. A poorly thought through idea for intl diplomacy but I understand why people might think it would help in their desperation. We know Putin is happy to kidnap orphans and commit horrific war crimes. That's true for Ukraine as well who's politicians idolise Nazi war criminal terrorist Stepan Bandera, and Ukie soldiers executed Russian POWs without trial - also unacceptable. The war is a cluster of epic proportion, I'm really not a fan of politicians who idolise Nazi war criminal terrorists like Stepan Bandera. At the same time, it's because Russia invaded first that I'm still hoping Ukraine don't lose this war to Russia - even if the way Ukraine's govt and soldiers have acted is indefensible at times The ongoing genocide in Gaza, the ongoing genocide in Darfur (sponsored by the West), the genocide in many other places ongoing is often downplayed by those who think Zelenskyy is some kind of perfect hero and the West should be allowed to invade Iraq and do whatever the heck it likes around the world. I dont have any problem with the Ukrainians fighting back against Russia, my point is about idiots parroting propaganda on how the Russians blew up their own pipeline. Do these people never engage brain? We all know in wars historically, the idea its good versus evil is fantasy for clowns who parrot propaganda to hallucinate over. We are told to ignore the azov battalion , or genocide in Gaza , but get annoyed by Russia attacking Ukraine. I prefer to do my own thinking. Others as you can see prefer to let the mainstream media do it for them .
|
|
|
Post by Zany on Aug 15, 2024 6:51:59 GMT
I'm sorry but that's complete crap. As a fan of historic architecture I can assure you there's plenty of it in England and it is preserved with a passion. Within 5 miles from my home there are two castles (one mid and one late medieval), a castle motte (probably the site of an early Norman wooden castle) and several dozen medieval churches plus the ruins of an Abbey (pulled down during the reformation). Just a mile away is a 13th century, half moated, fortified manor house (now a brewery and restaurant). No, it's not complete crap, look up how much has been preserved in Scotland compared to England, you did notice I said 'compared' didn't you? Much has been lost whereas their historical sites are much better preserved in Scotland, it's a precedent that dates a long way back. I never said EVERYTHING has been torn down in England - I said that much has been lost comparatively with Scotland where they have much more ancient historical sites, whereas we regularly destroyed ours to make way for new developments So what part of my post is 'complete crap' exactly? Note how you offer only one anecdotal example from nearby as proof for your claim by the way Now compare Edinburgh's historic areas to London's for a more complete comparison, we've destroyed our history a lot more than they have and that's a crying shame There are plenty of preserved buildings in England. Whether that matches Scotland per head of population or per square mile is academic. Of course more has gone from England 1, There was more, a lot more. England was developed for thousands of years before Scotland 2, England is the preferred place to live because of its climate and therefore has a much higher population density, this happened over thousands of years, so the suggestion that its "so much has been destroyed across large parts of England to make way for new developments with almost 0 regard for the historic value." is frankly nonsense.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 15, 2024 6:55:24 GMT
So you admit a lot more has gone from England, but I'm also "frankly" talking nonsense That doesn't seem at all contradictory
|
|
|
Post by Zany on Aug 15, 2024 7:03:07 GMT
So you admit a lot more has gone from England, but I'm also "frankly" talking nonsense That doesn't seem at all contradictory Its the WHOLE sentence which makes it nonsense. Not selected words You said; so much has been destroyed across large parts of England to make way for new developments with almost 0 regard for the historic value.I say much has gone deep back in history as England's population and farming grew. Nothing to do with new developments.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 15, 2024 7:16:30 GMT
Nearly all the examples I've read from England, real examples, indicated things such as road widening schemes, plans to build new bigger places or clearance to make way for something entirely different. But sure, I take your point about pasture for grazing and clearance for that too.
By the way, an argument can be made that 'new developments' in a historical context, not today, could encompass a broad range of things. I never said it's a modern thing after all.
Perhaps it's more accurate to refer specifically to new land for grazing, newly built space AND other amenities for the exploding population and new developments specifically. We all know pasture for grazing often means clearance of forest, potentially buildings and other similar things?
In that case I'm perfectly happy to admit I was inaccurate and amend my post as above ^ it also includes those other things and not just new developments, although that is definitely part of it. There's a good argument to be made they disregarded historic value of what they destroyed to make way for such
|
|
|
Post by Zany on Aug 15, 2024 7:34:46 GMT
Nearly all the examples I've read from England, real examples, indicated things such as road widening schemes, plans to build new bigger places or clearance to make way for something entirely different. But sure, I take your point about pasture for grazing and clearance for that too. By the way, an argument can be made that 'new developments' in a historical context, not today, could encompass a broad range of things. I never said it's a modern thing after all. Perhaps it's more accurate to refer specifically to new land for grazing, newly built space AND other amenities for the exploding population and new developments specifically. We all know pasture for grazing often means clearance of forest, potentially buildings and other similar things? In that case I'm perfectly happy to admit I was inaccurate and amend my post as above ^ it also includes those other things and not just new developments, although that is definitely part of it. There's a good argument to be made they disregarded historic value of what they destroyed to make way for such Not to mention wars, religious clearances and a host of other historical events in a fast developing country. One of the sad things we found on our various trips to France was that almost all their beautiful Chateaus were stripped bare in the revolution. All the beautiful contents you find in British stately homes are pretty much gone.
|
|
Steve
Hero Protagonist
Posts: 3,633
|
Post by Steve on Aug 15, 2024 8:55:49 GMT
I dont have any problem with the Ukrainians fighting back against Russia, my point is about idiots parroting propaganda on how the Russians blew up their own pipeline. . . . There is the possibility that this Ukrainian national could be one of those rebels that want the Donbas to become part of Russia.
|
|